Whether it be a pisco sour, espresso martini, or ramos gin fizz you’ve seen the cocktails with beautiful foam tops. Silky egg white makes for the most impressive creamy cocktails, and the mixologists who make drinks with them seem to have perfected the method for agitating the ingredients just right to get that foam to rise. But what you might not know is that there are two schools of thought around the best method for shaking: the dry shake versus the reverse dry shake. Which one is better? Let’s break it down.

The Dry Shake

The ‘dry shake’ is the more traditional technique mixologists use to get egg white cocktails (or vegan alternatives) to froth. It’s very simple – you just shake the egg white with all the other cocktail ingredients without ice to allow the mixture to combine without dilution (hence the phrase ‘dry shake’).

Then, after the ingredients have been agitated and become bubbly from the dry shake (usually about 2 minutes), ice is added to chill the liquid, gain the desired dilution, and further agitate the ingredients. The result? An irresistibly smooth foam that turns this gorgeous cocktail into basically a dessert.

The Reverse Dry Shake

There are those mixologists who claim that the opposite technique works even better – the ‘reverse dry shake’. As the name suggests, this is the inverse of a dry shake, where you begin by shaking the cocktail’s ingredients with ice first. It is then strained and shaken again, this time without ice, before serving.

Which is Better: the Dry Shake or Reverse Dry Shake?

Dry Shake vs Reverse Dry Shake

While both methods work very well, from personal experience we’ve found that a reverse dry shake will usually produce more foam, as the bubbles are larger, but with a less creamy texture. If you’re looking for a Ramos Gin Fizz with more drama, this may be a technique worth trying out.

Others argue that the reverse dry shake method introduces too much water into the drink, so if you’re aiming for more creaminess, stick with the dry shake method. 

Home mixologists may find that the dry shake is much easier for about the same result, as the reserve dry shake can be a bit of a pain. We tend to use the dry shake method most often when making our cocktails.

Either method is bound to produce a cocktail with major foam envy, so give each one a try and then stick to the one that brings you the most success. Still struggling to find the foam height you’re looking for? There are also those who have added a protein shaker ball or Hawthorne spring to the traditional dry shake method to create even more froth!